Can You Trust a Probability That Was Never Checked Against Reality?
Published:
Most risk dashboards report a number and ask you to trust it. A model says there is a 73 percent chance of an outbreak, and you have no way to know whether, across all the times it has said 73 percent, an outbreak actually followed 73 percent of the time, or 30 percent, or 95 percent. The number looks authoritative because it has a decimal point, but a probability that has never been checked against what actually happened is not really a probability. It is a feeling with a unit attached. I built MOSAIC in large part to take that problem seriously, and the discipline it forces, define a falsifiable quantity and then prove it is calibrated, turns out to matter far beyond epidemics.
